Papa John’s Hawaii Main Menu Pizza Small Cheese Pizza $14.98 Medium Cheese Pizza $22.78 Large Cheese Pizza $25.98 Extra Large Cheese Pizza $30.48 Small One Topping Pizza $14.98 Medium One Topping Pizza $22.78 Large One Topping Pizza $25.98 Extra Large One Topping Pizza $30.48 Small Two Topping Pizza $15.97 Medium Two Topping Pizza $24.57 Large