Gumbys Pizza Main Menu Popular Items Menu Cheese Pizza Price: $8.99+ Cinnamon Stix Fresh baked pizza dough covered with our gooey cinnamon topping then drizzled with vanilla icing. Yum Yum!! Price: $5.99+ Extra Pizza Sauce Price: $0.60 Original Pokey Stix Fresh baked pizza crust smothered with mozzarella cheese, garlic butter, and Italian spices. Served with